Rangers 2005 - nie przyznano z powodu lockoutu 2004 - Martin St. Louis, Tampa Bay Lightning oraz Marek Malik, Vancouver Canucks 2003 - Peter Forsberg i Milan Hejduk, Colorado Avalanche 2002 - Chris Chelios, Detroit Red Wings 2001 - Joe Sakic, Colorado Avalanche oraz Patrik Eliáš, New Jersey Devils 2000 - Chris Pronger, St. Louis Blues 1999 - John LeClair, Philadelphia Flyers 1998 - Chris Pronger, St. Louis Blues 1997 - John LeClair, Philadelphia Flyers 1996 - Władimir Konstantinow, Detroit Red Wings 1995 - Ron Francis, Pittsburgh Penguins 1994 - Scott Stevens, New Jersey Devils 1993 - Mario Lemieux, Pittsburgh Penguins 1992 - Paul Ysebaert, Detroit Red Wings 1991 - Marty McSorley, Los Angeles Kings oraz Theoren Fleury, Calgary Flames 1990 - Paul Cavallini, St. Louis Blues 1989 - Joe Mullen, Calgary Flames 1988 - Brad McCrimmon, Calgary Flames 1987 - Wayne Gretzky, Edmonton Oilers 1986 - Mark Howe, Philadelphia Flyers 1985 - Wayne Gretzky, Edmonton Oilers 1984 - Wayne Gretzky, Edmonton Oilers 1983 - Charlie Huddy, Edmonton Oilers